Nostalgic Candy

Filter by
Availability
Availability
116 results
Price
Price
116 results
$
$
Color
Color
116 results
Sort by Best Selling
Sort by

116 products

Look Bar
Quick buy
$2.25
Lifesavers Butter Rum
Quick buy
$2.45
Whatchamacallit
Quick buy
$2.00 Sold Out
Mallow Cup
Quick buy
$2.50
Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme Bar
Quick buy
$2.25 Sold Out
Chocolate Covered Big Hunk 1.5 Oz
Quick buy
$2.25 Sold Out
Sugar Babies
Quick buy
$2.75 Sold Out
Chunky
Quick buy
$2.50
Boston Baked Beans
Quick buy
From $0.75 Sold Out
Taffy salt water SINGLE
Quick buy
$0.25
Warheads Sour Booms
Quick buy
$2.50
Push Pop: Triple Power
Quick buy
$4.99 Sold Out
10' Unicorn Pops
Quick buy
$4.74 Sold Out
Beeman's Gum
Quick buy
$1.25
Cadbury Carmel Egg
Quick buy
$1.25 Sold Out
Now & Later
Quick buy
$0.75 Sold Out
Clove Chewing Gum
Quick buy
$1.25
Claeys Watermelon Drops
Quick buy
$2.50 Sold Out
Cadbury Creme Egg
Quick buy
$1.25 Sold Out
Almond Joy
Quick buy
$2.25
El Bubble II Original Bubble Gum Cigars
Quick buy
$1.25
3 Color Neapolitan Coconut Bar
Quick buy
$2.50
Now & Later Morphs
Quick buy
$2.50 Sold Out
Claeys Horehound Old Fashioned Hard Candies
Quick buy
$2.50