Nostalgic Candy

Filter by
Availability
Availability
128 results
Price
Price
128 results
$
–
$
Color
Color
128 results
Sort by Date, new to old
Sort by

128 products

 Quick buy
Sweetarts Mini Chewy Mixed Fruit 6oz
$4.75 Sold Out
Quick buy
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup
$2.25 Sold Out
Quick buy
Sugar Babies Movie Box
$2.75 Sold Out
Quick buy
Whoppers malted milk balls
$2.75 Sold Out
Quick buy
Werther’s original Chewy Caramels
$4.00 Sold Out
Candy Jackpot Slot Machine
Quick buy
Candy Jackpot Slot Machine
$3.50 Sold Out
SweeTarts Giant Chewy
Quick buy
SweeTarts Giant Chewy
$2.75 Sold Out
Puppy Love + Surprise
Quick buy
Puppy Love + Surprise
$2.50 Sold Out
Botan Rice Candy
Quick buy
Botan Rice Candy
$2.75 Sold Out
Big Spiral Gumball Machine
Quick buy
Big Spiral Gumball Machine
$3.50
Llama Doo
Quick buy
Llama Doo
$2.50 Sold Out
Mentos Fruit Rainbow Single Roll
Quick buy
Mentos Fruit Single Roll
$2.50
Crunchy Chewies Bubble Gum
Quick buy
Crunchy Chewies
$2.00
Baby Flash Pop
Quick buy
Baby Flash Pop
$2.25
Creme Savers: Strawberries & Creme
Quick buy
Creme Savers: Strawberries & Creme
$2.50
Original Cracker Jack
Quick buy
Original Cracker Jack
$3.75
Nestle Sno Caps
Quick buy
Nestle Sno Caps
$3.00
Nerds Big Chewy Bag
Quick buy
Nerds Big Chewy Bag
$4.75
La Pipette Candy Pipes
Quick buy
La Pipette Candy Pipes
$2.50 Sold Out
Clove Chewing Gum
Quick buy
Clove Chewing Gum
$1.25
Pop Ups! Lollipops : The Nightmare Before Christmas
Quick buy
Pop Ups! Lollipops : The Nightmare Before Christmas
$5.00 Sold Out
Taffy salt water SINGLE
Quick buy
Sugar Free Salt Water Taffy SINGLE
$0.25
Jelly Belly jelly beans Sugar Free
Quick buy
Jelly Belly jelly beans Sugar Free
$3.75 Sold Out
Toblerone Bar
Quick buy
Toblerone Bar
$2.00 Sold Out