All Products (Top Selling)

Shop our top-selling products at Blickenstaffs Toy Store in Provo, Utah! These are the bestselling toys, games, and gifts our customers love most — tried, tested, and proven crowd-pleasers. If you are not sure what to get, start here. Shop in store or online at blickenstaffs.com!

Filter by
Sort by Best Selling
Sort by

942 products

Googly Eyes Ball
Quick buy
Googly Eyes Ball
$7.00
Strawberry Sunset - Card Game - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Strawberry Sunset - Card Game
$16.00
Finger Claw
Quick buy
Finger Claw
$2.00
Red Mushroom Sticker - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Red Mushroom Sticker
$3.50
The Hair Book - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
The Hair Book
From $9.99
Quick buy
FlowArt Mini
$9.99
Quick buy
13 Dead End Drive
$45.00
Cat Parade Gel Crayons - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Cat Parade Gel Crayons
$20.95
Card Assassins: A Party Game - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Card Assassins: A Party Game
$16.00
Hogwarts Christmas Wreath and Wand Set - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Hogwarts Christmas Wreath and Wand Set
$13.95
Book of Mormon Aqua Brush Activity Book - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Scripture Aqua Brush Activity Books
$13.00
Finger Eyeballs
Quick buy
Finger Eyeballs - Finger Puppets
$2.00
Quick buy
Just One
$28.00
Stretchy Hand Puppets - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Stretchy Hand Puppets
$6.00
Quick buy
Love Letter: Bag Six Player Edition
$16.00
Mini Buddha Board - Black - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Buddha Boards
From $18.00
Quick buy
Rainy Day Gel Crayons
$22.00
Quick buy
Peach Blossom Wiggle Gel Pen
$2.50
Quick buy
Mille Bornes: The Classic Racing Game
$19.99
Mischief Maker Slingshot - Assorted Color - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Mischief Maker Slingshot
$24.00
Loopseez Bands Assorted Stlyes - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Loopseez Bands Assorted Stlyes
$2.75
Another Man's Treasure - Blickenstaffs Toy Store
Quick buy
Another Man's Treasure
$19.99
Quick buy
Rat-A-Tat Cat
$14.00
Quick buy
Bubs Sour Diamonds - Swedish Candy
$6.95