Shopping for a toddler? It can feel overwhelming — they're picky, they change their minds every five minutes, and half the toys you buy end up ignored in the corner. At Blickenstaffs Toy Store in Provo, Utah, we've been helping parents and grandparents find the perfect toddler gifts for over a decade. Here are our tried-and-true favorites.
What Makes a Great Toddler Toy?
The best toddler toys are open-ended, durable, and actually fun to play with. They spark imagination, survive being thrown across the room, and don't require batteries that die at the worst possible moment. Here's what we love.
1. Jellycat Stuffed Animals
Toddlers form deep attachments to their stuffed animals — and Jellycat makes the softest, most huggable plush toys in the world. The Bashful Bunny, Amuseable Cloud, and Blossom Bunny are perennial favorites. They're machine washable (mostly!) and built to last through years of love and squishing. Available in store and online at Blickenstaffs.
2. Nee Doh Squeeze Toys
Toddlers love sensory play, and Nee Doh delivers in spades. Squishy, stretchy, and completely safe — these stress balls are endlessly entertaining for little hands. Try the Cool Cats, the Groovy Fruit set, or the classic Original. Great for keeping tiny hands busy in the car, at restaurants, or anywhere you need a minute of peace.
3. Banwood First Go Balance Bike
The Banwood balance bike is one of the best gifts you can give a toddler ages 2-5. No pedals means they learn balance first — which makes the transition to a real bike incredibly easy. Lightweight steel frame, puncture-proof tires, and gorgeous colors. It's a gift they'll use every single day.
4. Scoot & Ride
A scooter and a ride-on toy in one — the Scoot & Ride grows with your child from ages 1 to 5. Incredibly well built and endlessly fun. One of the most popular gifts at Blickenstaffs for good reason.
5. Children's Board Books
Never underestimate a great board book! Toddlers love repetition, and a book they can request over and over builds language skills and a love of reading. We carry hundreds of carefully selected titles at Blickenstaffs — our staff can always point you to something great.
6. Pop Rocks and Novelty Candy
OK, hear us out — a little bag of Pop Rocks as a treat alongside a toy? Pure magic. Toddlers who are old enough (ages 3+) absolutely lose their minds over the popping sensation. A fun, inexpensive addition to any gift.
Shop Toddler Gifts at Blickenstaffs
Whether you're shopping for a first birthday, a big sibling gift, or just a Tuesday surprise, Blickenstaffs Toy Store in Provo has something perfect for every toddler. Visit us in store or shop online at blickenstaffs.com — we ship nationwide!
