Finding great stocking stuffers is an art. They need to be small enough to fit in a stocking, affordable enough to buy several, and exciting enough to actually delight the kids who find them on Christmas morning. After years of helping families shop at Blickenstaffs in Provo, Utah, we have it down to a science. Here are our absolute favorite stocking stuffers for 2026.

Under $5

Nee Doh Teenie Singles

Mini squeeze balls that are endlessly satisfying. Kids love collecting different colors and shapes. At under $5 each they are the perfect stocking filler.

Pop Rocks and Zotz

Novelty candy that surprises and delights — a stocking staple. Our Pop Rocks and Zotz are perennial bestsellers at Blickenstaffs.

Bouncy Balls and Wind-Up Toys

Simple, classic, and always exciting. Grab a handful of different styles.

Under $10

World's Smallest Toys

Fully functional miniature versions of classic toys — World's Smallest Etch-A-Sketch, Lite-Brite, Magic 8-Ball, and more. Kids and adults love these equally.

Nee Doh Original Squeeze Ball

The classic Nee Doh is always a hit. Cool to the touch, impossible to put down, and safe for ages 3+.

Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty 2-inch Tin

A perfect stocking stuffer — small, affordable, and genuinely fascinating. Color-changing, glow-in-the-dark, magnetic — there is a variety for everyone.

Under $20

Cover Your Assets Card Game

One of our all-time bestselling games — fast, fun, and works for all ages. A perfect stocking stuffer for families.

Nee Doh Nice Ice Baby Cube

Our number one selling product. Always cool to the touch, always returns to a perfect cube. A stocking stuffer that will be talked about all year.

Shop Stocking Stuffers in Utah

Visit Blickenstaffs at The Riverwoods in Provo, Utah or shop our stocking stuffer collection at blickenstaffs.com — we ship nationwide with free shipping on orders over $75!